Creative Cutters: More Than Just a Project

This site includes affiliate links. If you purchase from these links you will not pay more for the product, but I may earn a small commission which helps defray the costs of keeping the site running. I am also a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for me to earn commissions by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. I appreciate your support!

Like what you see? Share it!

Many Men Go Fishing
Source: RubyViral.com

“Many men go fishing all of their lives without knowing that it is not fish they are after.”

This is one of my husband’s favorite quotes. I’m not a man (duh!) nor do I fish, but I know exactly what he means when he says it. And it’s the first thing I thought of as our most recent Creative Cutters meeting finished up for the night.

You may already be wondering what fishing has to do with crafting. Stick with me for a few minutes and I’ll explain.

Creative Cutters

Like any good instructor, I test all projects (often multiple times) before I teach them. I try to anticipate where a student might have difficulties and brainstorm ways to avoid those difficulties. In class, I strive to create a positive and stress-free environment. If something happens, we back up, start over, and work our way through one step at a time until we figure it out.

Over time, I’ve learned to expect the unexpected and roll with the punches. I’ve dealt with technical issues, mis-cuts, weeding mistakes, melted HTV, power failures…you name it.  It’s all part of the process.

But there are some things you’re just not prepared for.

Not at all.

Like never in a million years.

Like a project that just refuses to be successful, despite being tested.

In other words, a project fail.

Yep, you read that right. A project FAIL! In one of MY classes, no less!!!  A simple project. A cute project. A project that I’d tested just like any other.

See this bright and cheerful chalkboard sign? I thought it would make a perfect project for our group to make on the eve of the first day of Spring. We’d only need a few things – the blank chalkboard, a stencil, paint, and some sponges. Sounds easy enough, right?

Welcome Spring Sign

But “easy”, it wasn’t.

Not at all.

Like never in a million years.

I’m still trying to figure out what happened.

Creative Cutters

As usual, I began with a few instructions. The stencils were applied, the paint was poured, and everyone started to paint. Sponge painting is simple. It’s relaxing. It’s FUN!!!

Everyone in the group was having a great time! People were mixing and matching colors and adding their own artistic touches to the design. There was lively conversation and lots of laughter.

Creative Cutters

Creative Cutters

And then it was time to pull off the stencils.

I don’t want to be over dramatic here. It’s not like I heard screams or gasps or anything else of that sort. (Pause for dramatic effect.) But there was a noticeable absence of the normal “oohs  and ahhs”.

That’s when I suspected we might have a problem.

I did hear a lot of “May I please have a touch-up brush?” and “Hmmmm, I wonder what happened here?”.

That’s when I knew we had a problem.

Seems that the beautiful acrylic paints we were using (you know, the same ones I tested) did NOT want to settle into their new home on our cute little chalkboard signs, preferring to remain instead with the lovely (although useless by this point) vinyl stencils. No matter what we tried, that paint wasn’t giving up without a fight! Some people’s paint had dried while other’s was still wet. Didn’t matter. Some paint was thin and some was thick. Didn’t matter. We used X-acto knives, pointed weeding tools, teamwork, and patience. DID. NOT. MATTER.

Creative Cutters

Oh, we had a few successes…thanks to sheer determination and a healthy dose of touch-up paint. But the majority of us went home with a blank chalkboard. (Because if the paint will pull up that easily with the stencil, any bits of paint that taunt you by remaining on the chalkboard can also be easily removed. Go figure.)

For the first time in the history of Creative Cutters, we had a project fail.

Or did we?

As you can imagine, all of this was quite discouraging. I had been looking forward to seeing everyone’s finished signs – painted all bright and cheery – not a bunch of blank black boards staring me in the face. And I’m pretty sure that wasn’t what anyone else anticipated either. (Talk about unmet expectations!)

But the evening itself wasn’t a failure at all, not by any stretch of the imagination. Some went home with blank chalkboards and others with painted chalkboards that didn’t turn out exactly like we planned, but we ALL went home with something better. A MEMORY. A GOOD memory actually. Some might even say it was a GREAT memory!

So you may think I’m crazy (and I kinda am at this point and maybe you are too for sticking with this story all the way to the end, LOL!), but with apologies in advance to Mr. Thoreau, I’m going to paraphrase by saying:

Caught by Design


“Many people craft all of their lives without knowing that it is not a finished project they are after.”


Despite all the troubles we had, everyone was still laughing at the end of the night. (Ok, maybe not “everyone”, because I certainly wasn’t laughing, but most everyone…) No one seemed stressed (that’s one point in the success column!). They even THANKED me as they left and told me they’d had FUN! (Huh?)

Maybe they were just trying to be polite, but I don’t think so. I truly believe it’s because when all is said and done, each of them know what we’re really after when we get together – not a finished project, but a shared experience. Time with friends and time to chat. A couple of hours to just forget whatever else is happening in the world and have some fun.

Creative Cutters

And this time, the teacher is the one who learned the lesson. Even when a project doesn’t turn out like you planned it, there really are no fails when you’re spending time with friends. And what a great group of friends I’ve got ♥.

Until next time,




P.S. While you’re here, why not leave a comment below and share one of your own crafting mishaps. I’m also soliciting tips on stencil painting, because clearly I still have a lot to learn 😉 .

Like what you see? Share it!


  1. My worst one to date is when my student did a lovely print and cut on printable HTV and when we pressed it (somehow) I had given her a different brand of printable HTV than the one I tested prior to class. I provided printable HTV which required a completely different temp and time – UGH!!!! What a mess… she loved the idea and was willing to try again! But what an epic fail 🙁

    1. Oh my….but I bet you won’t forget again! Given enough time, we’ll probably all have a story or two like that to tell. Thank you for being willing to share yours.

  2. How awesome Lycia for you to share your fails as well as your successes! Seems we are in a win only time now and I find it very refreshing to read your blog post. Like the previous comment, I have had many mishaps in my crafting life. I think it is part of our humility package! lol Thank you again for your time and knowledge. Jerri

  3. I’ve had too many mishaps to mention!! But I chalk it up to a learning experience! Crafting is fun and a stress reliever for me.

  4. Lycia,

    Having been in that place before…I love the attitude that you carried throughout the evening and the “memories” that you were given. Thank you for sharing. There is definitely a lesson to be taken from this.

  5. This is your greatest blog post yet! And you’ve had some really great ones. Making memories the Silhouette way!

  6. I didnt consider that night a fail at all. No, I didn’t get to go home with a pretty chalkboard, mine was one of the blank ones. But, the project itself was fun. The fellowship and laughter was great.. It was a night I got to spend with my granddaughters, who by the way, all had a blast, even one described it as comical, but fun. It was a night I got to spend with friends and family and learn a technique that this time, didnt work out, but it wont keep me from trying it again. You’re the Best, Lycia!!

    1. Hi Tammy! Thank you so much for those sweet words!!! I love having you and your granddaughters in class and am so happy to be making memories with you all 🙂 .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *